Talk:Malcolm Reed

This article states that the episode "E²" established that Reed remained single. However, I got the impression that he only said this to through Tucker off, as he then seeks out another crewmember. I felt it was implied that he had actually married her in the alternate future. Anybody else notice that?

I noticed that as well but I assumed that Malcolm had decided that if he didn't want to end up single that he'd have to try harder.

In "Silent Enemy", Hoshi learns that Malcolm doesn't like fish. In "Shuttlepod One", though, I believe he has Chilean Sea Bass as his last meal.

She does not precisely learn that he hates fish. His friend say, "I think he hates fish." Given that the entire point of that sub-plot was that even people who knew Reed did not know much about him, there is no reason to believe that a half assertion by a friend who doesn't know Reed that well would be entirely accurate. --OuroborosCobra ^talk 03:24, 1 February 2007 (UTC)

Removed Reed's Weakness - that of women - from Relationship section by Shran

Hi user:Shran, I strongly disagree with your removal of my original paragraph regarding Reed's weakness with women, here are my arguments:

1. Perhaps it should not be in the "relationships" section, as such an attribute is not EXACTLY a "relationship", but one could argue that this attribute of him obviously will affect his relationship with other women (for example, in a cutscene from Broken Bow, Reed jokes with Hoshi, with a sense of flirtation in his eyes). If NOT in the "relationships" section, perhaps it should be in some other section such as "personalities"?

2. I've read the entire article, unless I'm missing something, there's ABSOLUTELY NO MENTION of this weakness/attribute of Reeds, that he is easily enticed by sexy women (regardless of their species).

Please get back to me regarding these ideas. Perhaps we can work together somehow and make this key information into the article. – The preceding unsigned comment was added by Ubcphysicsyangbo (talk • contribs).

I support Shran's removal of that passage. As said by Shran, the portion about the two alien women in "Two Days..." is already mentioned. I also am not convinced that the remaining part of that passage is enough evidence to make such a definitive statement about a character's personality. It certainly isn't a relationship.--31dot 13:10, 2 March 2009 (UTC)

First, I would like to apologize for not adding the deleted information to the talk page as I was supposed to. For the record, here is what I removed:

However, Malcolm had an extraordinary weak spot when it came to beautiful females (human or otherwise). This is most prominently illustrated on a few occasions. For example, Malcolm was mesmerized by the dancing alien ladies performing with the butterflies on Rigel X ("Broken Bow"). Another example of this was during the pub visit of Malcolm and Trip in "Two Days and Two Nights". There are also numerous other occasions where Malcolm had succumb to this weakness.

As I stated in the edit summary, and as 31dot explained above, the info from "Two Days and Two Nights" was already in the article. As for the info being a testament to the character's personality, I have to agree with 31dot, there's just not enough evidence to make such a statement. If you can find more examples, you might be able to make a case for it, but I, personally, have never thought Reed to have a "weakness" for the ladies. The only episodes I can think of where his desire for women really gets him into trouble are "Two Days and Two Nights" (already described in the article) and "Bound", but in the latter, all the male crew members of Enterprise are affected by the Orions. But I don't think you can say that women were a particular weakness of his just because he was caught ogling a butterfly girl and just because he and Trip were looking for a one-night stand. Like I said, if you can find more evidence, go for it, but remember, as revealed in "E²", Reed is a man so involved with his duty that, in an alternate future, he never married and never had children. He hardly struck me as the type of guy with a weakness for the ladies. All due respect. :) --From Andoria with Love 20:10, 2 March 2009 (UTC)